Thwaites Has Collapsed Before — Every Time the World Got This Warm
The mud at the bottom of the sea remembers. And what it remembers about Thwaites Glacier should worry everyone who lives near a coast.
Scientists have drilled into the ocean floor near Antarctica, 4,000 metres below the surface. In the mud cores they found a warning from the past. Every time the Earth got as warm as it is today, the ice in West Antarctica collapsed.
The study was published on 10 November 2026 in Nature Communications. It was led by the British Antarctic Survey. And it is about the same glacier at the centre of the Cool Valley series: Thwaites, the Doomsday Glacier.
The Clue Hidden in the Clay
The clue is a mineral called kaolinite. Most people know it as china clay. It forms in warm, wet places. Long ago, more than 34 million years ago, it formed on Antarctica too. Today it sits locked in the rock under the West Antarctic Ice Sheet.
Only giant glaciers can grind it out. Thwaites and its neighbour, Pine Island Glacier, scrape the rock as they move. They carry the clay out to sea in icebergs and currents. So the mud on the ocean floor is full of kaolinite — as long as the glaciers are there.
But in every single warm period of the last 800,000 years, the kaolinite signal fell to almost zero. Every one. That means the ice was gone. The glaciers had melted and pulled back far into the interior of the continent.
"When the kaolinite signal at our drill-core sites suddenly collapses, it tells us the marine-based ice in the Amundsen Sea sector of the West Antarctic — including Thwaites and Pine Island glaciers — must have melted and retreated far back into the continent's interior," said Dr Claus-Dieter Hillenbrand, the British Antarctic Survey marine geologist who led the study. "It's the only way to explain why the delivery of kaolinite-rich debris to the ocean floor stops."
Warm Water Did It
The team also found the cause. A second clay mineral, smectite, appears in the mud at the same time the kaolinite disappears. This smectite comes from the deep Pacific Ocean floor, far to the north. Only warm deep-water currents could have carried it south to Antarctica.
Those same warm currents melted the ice from below. Tiny fossils in the mud confirm it. Diatoms, microscopic marine algae, change shape with water temperature. They show that the waters in front of the ice sheet were about 1 to 3 degrees Celsius warmer than today.
Here is the frightening part. The world as a whole was only 1.0 to 1.5 degrees warmer than pre-industrial times during those past warm periods. That is about the same as today. The planet is now about 1.47 degrees above pre-industrial levels. The local seas warmed far more than the global average.
What It Means for Sea Level
If Thwaites Glacier collapsed completely and melted into the ocean, it would raise global sea levels by 65 centimetres (26 inches). Pine Island Glacier could add another 51 centimetres (20 inches).
And if wider areas of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet went with them, sea levels could rise by 3 to 5 metres (10 to 16 feet). That would redraw the map of every coastal city on Earth.
In the past, this collapse took several thousand years. That is the one difference. Human greenhouse gas emissions are warming the oceans far faster than nature did. The scientists say the same process could now be compressed into centuries.
"What we found, to my surprise, is that even under natural conditions we had at least a partial collapse of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet. What we are doing now is making it much worse," Hillenbrand said.
"I'm personally convinced that future generations will see substantial sea-level rise," said Dr Rob Larter, a British Antarctic Survey marine geophysicist and co-author of the study. "How fast we'll see that rise is really difficult to say. This study shows that even in past natural warm periods we had a lot of ice loss, but what we're living in now is an interglacial on steroids."
Why Tomorrow Matters
On Thursday, 12 November, five mountain nations — Nepal, Bhutan, Kyrgyzstan, Pakistan and Tajikistan — will hold a high-level dialogue at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye. It is called "Advancing the Mountain Agenda". They will ask for climate finance and protection for mountain regions.
They asked for a formal agenda item on mountains at COP31. It was left off the formal list. The dialogue on Thursday is their next chance to be heard.
The mud from the Antarctic sea floor gives them a powerful argument. Thwaites has collapsed before, every time the world got this warm. The only question now is how fast it happens this time.
Sources: Claus-Dieter Hillenbrand et al., "Repeated loss of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet's Amundsen Sea sector during late Pleistocene interglacials", Nature Communications (2026), DOI: 10.1038/s41467-026-77004-2, via Phys.org, 10 November 2026 (British Antarctic Survey); ICIMOD, COP31 programme, 12 November 2026 high-level dialogue on the mountain agenda. Global temperature figure 1.47°C from WMO State of the Climate Update 2026. Images are illustrative.



Comments
Post a Comment